2005 Porsche Boxster Sports Car Reviews & Ratings

When it first appeared, the Porsche Boxster impressed us with its classic roadster look and road manners, but the interior styling and materials looked cheap and plasticky, and there lacked a general coherence to the switchgear and gauges.

That's all changed. The genuine leather is complemented by very nice fake leather and authentic-looking fake aluminum trim, the plastic looks expensive, and the layout is as pleasing to look as it is a rational display of various data. Function is improved with switches redesigned for easier use.

As it should be, the tachometer still has predominance in the three-gauge cluster. The instruments are black-faced in the Boxster and a light gray in the Boxster S, and their readability has been increased by a change from yellow to white LEDs. Data from the Sports Chrono system are displayed in the lower third of the tachometer's dial.

A spiffy new console integrates the climate controls and sound system, its revised set of switches a huge improvement over the previous unit. Here again, readability has been enhanced by a change to white LEDs. Music lovers can move up from the basic system to Porsche Sound Package Plus, which somehow manages to fit in seven speakers, an external analog amplifier, two tweeters, a subwoofer in the instrument panel, and door-mounted woofers and subwoofers on each side. If that isn't enough to pound your eardrums into submission, consider the 11-speaker Bose surround sound system, which includes a seven-channel amplifier. Top-down enjoyment of your tunes isn't too badly compromised.

Should finding your way around be an issue, fitting Porsche Communication Management ($2,640) makes sense. The nav system is now DVD-based via a separate module in the front trunk, which frees up the dash-mounted CD drive for music discs. And notice we said "front" trunk. One of the Boxster's delights is stowage both fore and aft, with no compromise to the rear trunk's 4.6 cubic feet even when the top is stowed away. Unlike many other two-seaters, the Boxster can actually haul enough luggage for an extended road trip for two.

And what a trip that would be in this bigger, better Porsche Boxster. It feels all grown up, self-assured and solid in purpose, as though it no longer has to lag behind in the shadow of its big brother.

You feel this move into maturity as soon as you settle into the redesigned seats. Despite being larger, they're also stronger and lighter than the outgoing chairs, and Porsche even developed a patented vibration dampening system to reduce road buzz. But you will get a buzz just from turning the key, because when the Boxster's flat six burbles to life, there's no mistaking it for anything but a sports car engine. Both displacements received improvements to their respective intake and exhaust systems, boosting maximum outputs (240 hp; S: 280 hp) but also adding muscle to the torque curves where it counts.

Porsche claims the base Boxster can sprint from 0 to 60 mph in 5.9 seconds; 5.2 seconds for the 3.2. Top speeds are 159 mph for Boxster; 167 mph for Boxster S. Porsche's factory performance numbers are generally on the conservative side. Both cars, incidentally or not depending on your geo-political bent, qualify as Low Emissions Vehicles. Both cars, not incidentally, are quite fast enough to satisfy any delinquent desires. If anyone needs to get to 100 mph in less than 14.5 seconds (S: 12.3 seconds), then check into the next Skip Barber driving school for therapy.

Proper sports cars, it has long been contended, have three pedals on the floor, and so it is with the Boxster. At their very best, sports car drivers are one-person jazz combos, juggling the interplay of shifter, steering wheel and pedals in a polyrhythmic balance of manual dexterity. Remove the clutch and it just ain't the same.

Granted, some of the latest automatics are so good that electronic de-clutching should no longer be considered so shameful. There's certainly no shame driving a Boxster with Tiptronic S, which is pretty good for the species and would be the logical choice if your Boxster is condemned to a life of urban crawl. This newest version sports revised differential gearing and retuned software to maximize the shift behaviors, especially to avoid excessive "hunting" during upgrades and descents, and a new transmission fluid recipe extends the replacement interval to 112,000 miles. If a Boxster fell out of the sky and it was equipped with Tiptronic S instead of our preferred manual, we would no doubt find a way to be content with our good fortune. Besides, there's something deliciously decadent about reaching deep into the engine's power reserves simply by pushing a button.

But, Porsche does manual shifting as well as anyone, and there's no reason for even the ham-fisted (ham-footed?) to fear the clutch. In fact, you lazy left-footers don't know what you're missing. Doing what they do, Porsche's engineers made the best even better for the new Boxster via reinforced synchromesh rings and additional multiple synchromesh elements (for both manuals), allowing the practiced driver to feel as confident slipping the shift lever into its proper position as a magician sliding a card into the middle of the deck. In short, we recommend going for the manual.

This empowering of the driver is at the heart of all good sports cars. And at the heart of that heart is a good, balanced chassis. The Boxster has from inception been the epitome of balance, which is key to all controlled movement, at least in the physics of this universe. Porsche, thankfully, operates in a slightly different timeframe than most car makers, where "balanced" is a constantly evolving state. Upgrades are developed as soon as a component reaches production, but rarely does a Porsche platform get such a thorough overhaul as did the new Boxster. Though the basic suspension layout remains as before, almost every element was re-engineered, from its retuned springs and shocks to larger wheel bearings, from its wider front track to the stiffer but lighter rear suspension.

The result is a bigger helping of sports car goodness, a more savory blend of power and control. Even with a curb weight of some 3,000 pounds, the Boxster is like a dancer that seems able to accept or reject gravity's rule as it suits its own, artful progress down the road. Of the 44 pounds of weight added to the new Boxster, 40 of them were invested in making the car's structure stiffer and stronger. Torsional stiffness was increased by 9 percent and resistance to flex enhanced by 14 percent. Stiffer is better when it comes to building sports car chassis.

A truly utilitarian beast, the Boxster's two luggage compartments can swallow a diva's wardrobe. "Where's the engine?" can be a droll game to play on friends and family; not only is the flat six tucked out of sight amidships, there's not even a dipstick to point the way to its lair. Oil level is now measured electronically, so put away that greasy rag. No need to dip and wipe. When the engine starts to dry up, a friendly gauge will fulfill its function and let you know.

The Boxster's soft top (which can now be opened or closed at speeds up to 31 mph) was reengineered. The top uses a light synthetic fleece fiber to better insulate against rain, cold and noise, and it includes an electrically heated rear glass window. The optional hardtop is made of aluminum and adds 51 pounds to the scale.

In our previous stints with the Boxster, though, we've usually run with only the heavens over our heads. It's a comfortable convertible, and wind noise becomes detrimental to the pleasure of the open top only above extra-legal speeds. An enlarged air deflector does a good job of redirecting the air blasts, but our personal sense of style has precluded us from using it in the past, as it mars the svelte profile of this handsome roadster.

Okay, so we don't mind that we somehow look better in a Boxster, always a hoped-for side effect of driving a sports car. Style doesn't get you around a corner, though, and this is where many modern cars which claim the sports car moniker fail to connect with the driver. There is too much technological intervention, leaving the driver (and the terrified passenger) little left to do but hang on. This kind of motoring is scary fast, because the inexorable laws of physics that control the car's fate are muted, as is the control exerted by the driver. The Boxster is the better example. Fast, but the speed constantly streams with data, connecting and reconnecting the driver to the steering, brakes and throttle.

Porsche Boxsters come in two flavors, fast and faster. The base Boxster ($43,800) sports a 240-horsepower 2.7-liter flat six that mates to a newly developed standard five-speed manual transmission. The Boxster S ($53,100) is fitted with a 280-horsepower 3.2-liter flat six and a six-speed gearbox. The six-speed gearbox can also be ordered on the base Boxster as part of a Sports Package ($2,680) that includes Porsche's new Active Suspension Management system (PASM). For those who prefer automatic transmissions, Porsche's five-speed automatic Tiptronic S ($3,210) is an option for either Boxster model.

Safety improvements are among the most significant changes to the new Boxster. New passive safety features include a unique head airbag protection system, a first for any roadster and just one aspect of a wide array of safety systems and structures. Night vision can be enhanced by a bi-xenon headlamp option ($990), and fitting into tight spaces made easier by Park Assist ($530). Dynamic safety was increased by the simple expedient of fitting larger brakes, wheels and tires. For the first time the front brake rotors are cross-drilled, gripped by four-piston aluminum monobloc calipers. Don't worry about what that means except that these are among the best brakes in any production car.

Standard running gear for the Boxster is 6.5x17 up front and 8x17 in back, mounted with 205/55 and 235/50 performance radials, front and rear. The S gets 8x18s at the nose and 9x18s under the tail, wrapped by 235/50s and 265/40s, fore and aft. Boxsters can be ordered with the 18-inch S wheels ($1,235) or one of the three 19-inch wheels that also are optional on the S ($2,785 on the Boxster; $1,550 on the S). These big units measure 8x19 in front and 9.5x19 in back and roll on ultra-low-profile tires.

If you're the kind of driver who might, on occasion, want to stretch PASM's sensors to the max, consider ticking off the box for the Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes ($8,150). Not that the standard brakes are underachievers. Still, the composite brakes are from another world of deceleration. They give your right foot the sure-edged sensitivity of a diamond cutter, and they also reduce unsprung mass by almost 35 pounds, which helps make the Boxster feel more like a lithe dancing partner than a two and a half ton hunk of technology.

As with all Porsches, the need to be pampered is fully satisfied in even a bare-bones Boxster, which really isn't close to being anything like a stripper. Leather adorns the steering wheel rim, shift lever, handbrake lever and door handles; the air is conditioned and the ears are assaulted by, respectively, automatic climate control and a stereo tuner/CD unit; roof, mirrors and windows are all at the electronic mercy of thoughtfully placed switches.

But, as with every Porsche, many thousands of dollars can be added to the bottom line with just a few ticks of the options list. So why not start with a full leather interior ($2,045)? Then check out the wide range of seating options: six-way adjustable seats are standard; the first of three options is full 12-way power-adjustable seats with pneumatic lumbar support; second is sport seats based on the standard seats but with more side support; and third is adaptive sport seats with full electric adjustment, plus individual adjustment of the various side supports ($3,050). Heated seats are also available ($480).

If you don't want the standard three-spoke steering wheel, it can be supplanted by a choice of two additional configurations: a smaller diameter sport wheel or a multi-function wheel fitted in conjunction with the optional Porsche Communication Management system ($2,640). Stereo freaks can upgrade to a Bose Surround Sound system ($1,665 in the Boxster; $950 in the S) and put a six-disc changer in the front trunk ($650).

Gadget freaks, and drivers wanting the get the most out of their Boxsters, will definitely want to order the Sport Chrono Package Plus ($920). Its most obvious element is a clock-style gauge sitting atop the dashboard, which does indeed act just as it looks, charting sprint or lap times. But, along with these functions, SCPP also interacts with the engine management system, PSM, PASM and Tiptronic S (if those are fitted) to provide a sportier driving experience through quicker throttle response, faster shifts and higher limits to the anti-spin control thresholds. All those aspiring to be the coolest Boxster owners better have Sport Chrono. And as long as we're going after the ultimate Boxster, why not order up a custom paintjob? Just supply a sample (and $4,315), and you'll have a Boxster that looks like no other.

So, how much have we added to the Boxster's base price? We'll let you do the math depending on your wish list, but we suspect there might be a few $70,000 Boxsters out there soon. Yikes!